For heating & cooling, plumbing, & electrical needs

Find your location

Submit

Gas vs. Electric Furnace: How to Choose the Right Option for Your Home

Brr! When that winter chill hits, nothing matters more than having a reliable furnace keeping your home cozy. These days, homeowners facing furnace replacement often get stuck at a crossroads – gas or electric? While both keep your toes warm, picking between them isn’t quite as simple as flipping a coin.

Truth is, what works perfectly for your neighbor might be totally wrong for your situation. Energy costs in your area, the size of your home, local climate, and even access to natural gas lines all play a part in this decision. Plus, there’s more to think about than just the upfront price tag – monthly bills, maintenance costs, and environmental impact can really add up over the years.

Ready to sort through the facts about gas and electric furnaces? We’ve broken down everything from efficiency ratings to installation requirements, giving you the real scoop on both options. No fancy jargon or sales pitch – just straight talk about what matters when choosing your next heating system.

Overview of Gas Furnaces

Gas furnaces continue to heat millions of American homes, standing as a time-tested solution for reliable home heating. These systems tap into natural gas or propane to create warmth through a proven process that’s been refined over decades of use.

How Gas Furnaces Work

The heating cycle begins when your thermostat calls for warmth. At this point, the furnace sparks to life – its burner ignites incoming gas in the combustion chamber. The resulting flame warms up the heat exchanger, which then transfers this heat to air moving through your ductwork. A blower fan keeps this warmed air flowing steadily through your home’s vents.

Key Components

Gas furnaces rely on several essential parts working together:

  • Burners to create the initial flame
  • Heat exchanger to warm the passing air
  • Blower system for air movement
  • Ventilation setup for exhaust
  • Built-in safety controls

Heating Power

When it comes to raw heating capability, gas furnaces pack quite a punch. Their output typically ranges from 40,000 to 120,000 BTUs, delivering the muscle needed to keep homes cozy even during harsh winters.

Efficiency Ratings

Today’s gas furnaces have come a long way in efficiency. Look for AFUE ratings between 80% and 98% – these numbers tell you how much of your fuel actually becomes heat. For example, a 95% AFUE furnace turns nearly all its fuel into usable warmth, wasting very little through exhaust.

For homes with access to natural gas lines, these systems offer a practical blend of powerful heating and improved efficiency that’s tough to beat.

Overview of Electric Furnaces

Electric furnaces have gained significant traction as a straightforward heating solution, particularly in regions without easy access to natural gas lines. These systems turn electrical energy directly into heat through a surprisingly simple process.

How Electric Furnaces Work

Unlike their gas counterparts, electric furnaces skip the combustion process entirely. When your home needs warmth, electric heating elements – similar to what you’d find in a toaster but much larger – heat up. A blower fan then pushes air across these hot elements, warming it before sending it through your home’s ductwork.

Key Components

Electric furnaces keep things uncomplicated with fewer moving parts:

  • Electric heating elements
  • Blower motor and fan
  • Sequence controller
  • Safety limit switches
  • Air filter system

Heating Output

Most residential electric furnaces deliver between 10 and 25 kilowatts of heating power. For comparison, a 20-kilowatt unit puts out around 68,000 BTUs of heat – plenty for many homes, though typically less than gas systems offer.

Safety Features

Without any fuel burning or carbon monoxide concerns, electric furnaces bring built-in peace of mind. They still include important safety features like:

  • Automatic shutoff protection
  • Temperature limit controls
  • Air pressure switches
  • Circuit breaker integration

While electric furnaces might cost more to run in some areas, their straightforward operation and minimal maintenance needs make them an attractive choice for many homeowners, especially in milder climates or areas without natural gas service.

Key Differences Between Gas and Electric Furnaces

Let’s cut through the confusion and lay out exactly what sets gas and electric furnaces apart. These differences can make a huge impact on your home comfort, so it’s worth taking a closer look.

Heat Production and Delivery

Gas systems pack more punch up front – they blast out seriously warm air between 120-140 degrees through your vents. Electric furnaces take a gentler approach, pushing out air around 85-95 degrees. This means electric units often need to run longer to get your home just as cozy.

Installation Needs

Getting a gas furnace up and running takes some work. You’ll need proper venting, gas lines, and safety detectors in place. Electric furnaces keep things simpler – just hook up the right electrical circuits and ductwork, and you’re mostly set.

Warming Speed

Want quick heat? Gas furnaces jump right into action, warming your space fast once they fire up. Electric systems take their time, gradually building up warmth. During those bitter cold snaps, you’ll really notice this difference.

How Long They Last

The simpler design of electric furnaces helps them stick around longer – often 20-30 years with good care. Gas furnaces usually give you 15-20 good years, mainly because their parts work harder dealing with the whole combustion process.

Safety Setup

With gas furnaces, you’ve got to stay on top of carbon monoxide and gas leak risks. Regular safety checks are a must. Electric furnaces skip these worries, though they still need basic electrical safety once-overs.

Space Demands

Gas units need breathing room – literally. They require space for proper ventilation and safety clearances. Electric furnaces can squeeze into tighter spots since they don’t need all that extra ventilation setup.

Understanding these key differences helps point you toward the better choice for your home setup and heating needs.

Pros and Cons of Gas Furnaces

Before you jump into buying a gas furnace, let’s get real about what you’re getting into. Here’s the straight talk about where gas furnaces really shine – and where they might give you headaches.

What’s Great About Gas Furnaces

Gas furnaces can really crank out the heat when you need it most. They’ll warm up your place in no time flat, which makes a huge difference during those freezing winter nights. Plus, in most areas, running a gas furnace won’t break the bank each month. Many homeowners love that their gas furnace keeps working even when the power’s out.

The Not-So-Great Stuff

Here’s the catch – gas furnaces need some serious attention to stay safe. You’ll need yearly check-ups to watch for carbon monoxide issues, and installation isn’t exactly a DIY job. They also need proper venting, which can be tricky in some homes. And if you don’t already have gas lines? That’s another whole project to tackle.

Pros and Cons of Electric Furnaces

Now let’s talk electric furnaces – they’re a whole different ball game. Here’s what you should know before going electric.

The Good News

Electric furnaces keep things pretty simple. No gas lines, no carbon monoxide worries, and they run quieter than your neighbor’s gas unit. They’re built to last, too – many keep running strong for decades with basic care. Plus, they’re about as efficient as heating gets, turning almost all their energy into warmth.

The Rough Spots

Let’s be honest – electric furnaces can hit your wallet hard each month. When temperatures really drop, they take their sweet time warming things up. And if your power goes out? So does your heat. Some older homes might even need electrical upgrades to handle these power-hungry systems.

Bottom line? Both types can work great – it just depends on what matters most to you. Think about your climate, your budget, and what kind of maintenance you’re willing to handle. What works like a charm in one home might be totally wrong for another.

Factors to Consider When Choosing

Before you settle on a gas or electric furnace, let’s walk through the key factors that should shape your decision. Getting this right means staying cozy without any buyer’s remorse down the road.

Your Local Climate

Think hard about your winter weather. Gas furnaces really prove their worth in areas that see bitter cold snaps, while electric units often do just fine in milder regions. If temperatures regularly drop below freezing, that gas furnace’s extra heating muscle might be worth its weight in gold.

Your Home’s Setup

Take a good look at what you’re working with:

  • Already have gas lines? That’s a big point for gas furnaces
  • Older electrical system? Might need upgrades for electric
  • Limited space? Electric units typically need less room
  • Existing ductwork? Either type can work with it

Energy Rates in Your Area

Your local utility rates make a huge difference. Some regions offer dirt-cheap natural gas but steep electrical rates – or vice versa. Check both current rates and past trends in your area before deciding.

Home Size Matters

Bigger homes usually benefit from gas furnaces’ stronger heating power. Smaller spaces or well-insulated homes might do just fine with electric heat. Consider your square footage and insulation quality carefully.

Long-Term Plans

Think about how long you’ll stay put:

  • Planning to sell soon? Consider what buyers in your area prefer
  • Staying for decades? Factor in long-term maintenance needs
  • Thinking about solar panels? An electric furnace might make more sense

Comfort Preferences

Some folks love the intense heat blast from gas furnaces. Others prefer the steady, more gradual warmth of electric units. Consider what makes you most comfortable.

Remember – there’s no one-size-fits-all answer here. The right choice depends on your specific situation and what matters most to you.

Installation and Maintenance Differences

Let’s talk about what you’re really getting yourself into with each type of furnace. The setup and upkeep between gas and electric units couldn’t be more different, and you’ll want to know what’s ahead before making your choice.

Getting Things Started

Want a gas furnace? Better roll up your sleeves. You’re looking at some serious installation work. Your home needs the right venting setup, solid gas line connections, and those crucial carbon monoxide detectors. Plus, you’ve got to leave enough breathing room around the unit for safety’s sake.

Electric furnaces? They’re more of a plug-and-play deal. Hook up the ductwork, wire up a beefy electrical circuit, and you’re mostly good to go. No fancy venting or extra safety gear needed.

Keeping Things Running

Gas Furnace Care

These systems need some serious attention:

  • Can’t skip those yearly safety checks
  • Gotta keep those burners clean
  • Watch that heat exchanger like a hawk
  • Clean out those vents
  • Fresh filters every couple months

Electric Furnace Upkeep

Much more laid back:

  • Quick yearly once-over
  • Check those heating elements
  • Keep the blower clean
  • Swap filters regularly
  • Make sure connections stay tight

Getting Help

Here’s the deal – gas furnaces aren’t your weekend warrior project. When something goes wrong, you’ll need a pro. Too many safety issues to mess around with. Electric units give you more wiggle room for DIY fixes, but don’t get too cocky with the big stuff.

Life Expectancy

Take care of your gas furnace, and you’ll get a solid 15-20 years. Electric units are the marathon runners – they’ll often keep kicking for 20-30 years if you treat them right. Either way, skip the maintenance and you’re asking for trouble.

Bottom line? Neither type’s maintenance-free, but at least now you know what you’re signing up for.

Trust Bassett Services for Your Next Furnace

Look, picking between gas and electric furnaces isn’t always straightforward. But getting the right team to handle your installation? That’s the easy part.

Here at Bassett Services, we’ve been keeping Indiana and Ohio homes cozy for over 40 years. We’re not your average HVAC company – we’re a better breed of heating service provider, and our track record proves it. Just ask any of our 2,200+ happy customers.

Whether you’re leaning toward gas or electric, our pros know these systems inside and out. No tricks, just treats – that’s how we do business. We’ll help you pick the perfect furnace and install it right, guaranteed.

Ready to upgrade your home’s heating? Sound the hound and give us a buzz at (317) 360-0054. From initial consultation to final installation, we’ve got your back. Let’s get your home ready for whatever winter throws our way.

Our Promises

OVER 40 YEARS OF HAPPY CUSTOMERS

RESPECTFUL FAMILY FRIENDLY SERVICE

CONVENIENT PAYMENT OPTIONS