For heating & cooling, plumbing, & electrical needs

Find your location


When Should You Replace Your Water Heater?

Tackling home upkeep tasks can be quite challenging, particularly when it’s about crucial home appliances like your water heater. This key home element often goes unnoticed, but its importance becomes starkly apparent the moment you face unexpected issues like lukewarm showers or a dripping tank. So, the pivotal question emerges: When is it time to replace your water heater?

Grasping the optimal timing for this replacement is not only about ensuring comfort; it’s about maximizing efficiency, securing safety, and achieving a sense of security in your household. In this guide, we will dive into the essential indicators that signal the need for a water heater replacement. Whether you’re grappling with an old unit, pondering over energy-efficient options, or preemptively planning, this piece aims to arm you with the knowledge required to make a well-rounded choice.

When Should You Replace Your Water Heater? – The Overall Perspective

Determining the right moment to replace your water heater hinges on a few key elements, with the age of the unit being a paramount factor. On average, conventional tank-based water heaters last between 8 to 12 years, while their tankless counterparts can function efficiently for over 20 years. Remember, these are just estimations, and the actual lifespan can be influenced by factors such as maintenance diligence, frequency of usage, and the quality of your water supply.

Age isn’t the only factor; the efficacy and performance of your water heater are just as crucial. Older water heaters often lose their efficiency, leading to higher utility costs and inadequate hot water supply. A noticeable degradation in performance or efficiency can often signal that your water heater is nearing the end of its service life.

Repair costs are another consideration. Older water heaters might need more frequent repairs that can be expensive. Eventually, the financial wisdom tilts towards swapping out an aging unit for a fresh, high-efficiency model rather than persisting with repairs on the current one. Moreover, the advancements in water heater technology have ushered in a new era of markedly superior energy efficiency in newer models. This presents an opportunity not just for enhanced performance but also for greater energy savings and a lower environmental impact.

In the upcoming sections, we will delve deeper into these considerations, examining the telltale signs that it’s time for your water heater to be replaced, the advantages of switching to an energy-efficient model, and much more. So keep reading!

How Long Do Water Heaters Last?

Determining the lifespan of your water heater isn’t a straightforward affair; it varies depending on multiple factors such as the type of heater, how well it’s maintained, the quality of its installation, and the characteristics of the local water supply. In this section, we will delve into the various aspects that determine how long your water heater can be expected to last, offering a detailed perspective to help you anticipate the need for replacement.

Type of Water Heater

The most common types of water heaters are tank and tankless models, and each has its own typical lifespan.

Tank Water Heaters

The conventional choice in numerous households, feature a sizable tank responsible for storing and heating water. On average, tank water heaters last about 8-12 years.

Factors such as the material of the tank, the quality of the water supply, and how often maintenance is performed can all play a role in determining the lifespan of the water heater. Tanks made from materials like fiberglass are less prone to corrosion compared to steel, potentially offering a longer lifespan.

Tankless Water Heaters

Alternatively referred to as on-demand water heaters, heat water directly without the need for a storage tank. They generally last longer than tank models, with an expected lifespan of around 20 years or more. The longer lifespan of tankless water heaters is in part attributable to the absence of a tank, which mitigates risks associated with tank-related issues such as corrosion and leaks.


Routine maintenance plays a pivotal role in prolonging the lifespan of all water heaters. Performing tasks like annual tank flushing to eliminate sediment buildup, monitoring the pressure relief valve, and conducting inspections for wear and leaks are crucial for extending the longevity of tank water heaters. Similarly, for tankless models, regular cleaning of filters and checking the heating elements are indispensable practices.

Installation Quality

Proper installation plays a critical role in the lifespan of a water heater. Improper installation can lead to a host of problems, including inefficient operation, increased wear and tear, and even safety hazards. It’s essential to enlist the services of a qualified professional for the installation and setup of your water heater, ensuring adherence to the manufacturer’s specifications.

Water Quality

The lifespan of your water heater can be significantly impacted by the quality of water in your area. Hard water, which is high in minerals like calcium and magnesium, can lead to quicker accumulation of sediment in the tank. The accumulation of sediment can diminish the efficiency of the heater and raise the risk of corrosion and leaks.

Usage Patterns

The amount of hot water your household consumes also impacts the lifespan of your water heater. Increased demand places greater stress on the unit, potentially accelerating wear and tear.

Recognizing these factors aids in anticipating when your water heater may require replacement. While the average lifespans provide a general guideline, paying attention to your unit’s performance, maintenance, and the specific conditions in your home will offer a more accurate prediction of its longevity. By keeping a close eye on these aspects, you can ensure that your water heater serves you effectively for as long as possible.

Signs Your Water Heater Is Going Bad

While some signs of a failing water heater are commonly known, such as leaks or a complete lack of hot water, there are several less obvious indicators that can signal your unit is nearing the end of its lifespan. Recognizing these more subtle signs can enable you to address issues before they escalate into significant problems or complete system failures. Let’s delve into some of these less common indicators in detail.

Inconsistent Water Temperatures

If you begin to notice fluctuations in water temperature that aren’t related to simultaneous use in different parts of your home, it could be a sign of a failing heating element or thermostat in your water heater.

Slow Recovery Time

Pay attention to how quickly your water heater recovers after extensive use. If it takes significantly longer than usual to reheat the water, this could indicate a decline in the efficiency of the heating elements or burners.

Unusual Sounds from Sediment Buildup

While some noise is normal, pay attention to sounds like popping, cracking, or rumbling. These can be signs of sediment buildup at the bottom of the tank, which not only reduces efficiency but also can lead to overheating and damage to the tank lining.

Tinted or Murky Hot Water

If the hot water starts to appear slightly tinted, usually rusty or muddy in color, it could be a sign of corrosion inside the tank or in the pipes. This issue might not always be immediately evident but can significantly affect the unit’s performance and longevity.

Decreased Water Pressure

A sudden or gradual decrease in hot water pressure can be a symptom of sediment buildup inside the tank or on the fixtures. Over time, this can lead to clogging and reduced efficiency.

Moisture or Mildew Near the Unit

Beyond obvious leaks, the presence of moisture or mildew around the base of the water heater can indicate small, undetected leaks or condensation issues, which can corrode the water heater over time.

Age-Related Inefficiency

While not a sign you can see or hear, an understanding of your water heater’s age can be critical. If your unit is approaching or has surpassed its expected lifespan and is showing even minor signs of malfunction, it’s a strong indicator that it’s time for a new one.

Frequent Resetting Required

If you find yourself frequently needing to reset the water heater, this is often a sign of an underlying issue that’s causing the unit to trip its safety features. This could result from electrical issues, a malfunctioning thermostat, or a faulty heating element.

Changes in Water Quality

Apart from discoloration, if you start noticing a metallic taste or an increase in mineral deposits on dishes and fixtures, it’s a sign that the interior of the tank is breaking down.

Persistent Pilot Light Issues

Common in gas water heaters, such as repeated extinguishing or difficulty in lighting, may signal potential problems with the gas supply or venting system.

Recognizing these signs early can be key in preventing a complete water heater failure and avoiding the inconvenience and costs associated with emergency replacements. Regular maintenance and early detection of these issues can extend the life of your water heater and ensure it operates efficiently.

Is It Worth Repairing a Water Heater?

Determining whether to repair or replace a water heater is a critical decision for homeowners. This choice is not just about immediate costs but also involves considering long-term efficiency, future expenses, and the overall comfort of your home. In this section, we’ll explore this dilemma from a unique perspective, focusing on factors that aren’t often highlighted in the usual repair-or-replace debate.

Assessing the Age-Related Performance

The age of your water heater plays a significant role in this decision. If your unit is nearing the end of its typical lifespan (around 8-12 years for tank heaters, 20 years for tankless), investing in repairs might be less economical. As water heaters age, their components degrade and efficiency declines, resulting in more frequent and expensive repairs.

Assessing Energy Efficiency Improvements

Advancements in technology have rendered modern water heaters more energy-efficient. If your current water heater is an older model, repairing it may mean missing out on potential savings on your energy bills. Investing in a new, more efficient model could yield long-term benefits by lowering utility expenses.

Considering Environmental Impacts

Eco-conscious homeowners might want to consider the environmental impact of their decision. Older models are less energy-efficient and environmentally friendly compared to newer ones. Transitioning to a newer model can diminish your carbon footprint.

Unique Features and Needs

If your current water heater lacks certain features that are now standard in newer models, like improved safety mechanisms or smart technology integrations, upgrading could bring more than just hot water. Upgrading could improve the overall safety and functionality of your home.

Analyzing Repair Costs vs. Replacement Costs

Sometimes, the cost of repairing a water heater, especially if it involves critical components like the tank itself, can be high enough to warrant consideration of a replacement. A general guideline is that if the repair cost exceeds 50% of the replacement cost, it may be more economical to replace the unit.

Impact on Property Value

For those considering selling their home, a new water heater can be a selling point. Prospective buyers often seek homes that won’t necessitate immediate maintenance. In this case, replacing an old or malfunctioning water heater could enhance the appeal and value of your property.

Future Proofing Your Home

As we move towards more sustainable living practices, considering how your water heater fits into this future is essential. Upgrading to a more efficient and durable model now might be a proactive step towards aligning with future environmental standards and practices.

Although repairing a water heater might offer short-term cost savings, it’s crucial to contemplate these broader aspects. Assessing your current water heater’s age, efficiency, and the potential benefits of new features, alongside environmental considerations and property value implications, will help you make a more informed and future-forward decision.

How Much Does It Cost to Replace a Water Heater?

Replacing a water heater is a significant investment, and homeowners naturally want to understand the financial implications. The cost can fluctuate significantly based on various factors, such as the type of water heater, capacity, energy efficiency, installation intricacy, and geographic location. Let’s break down these costs to provide a clearer picture.

Type of Water Heater

The choice between tank and tankless water heaters greatly affects the cost.

Tank Water Heaters

These are typically less expensive, with prices ranging on average from $400 to $1,500 for the unit itself. They are often less costly to install, given their straightforward setup.

Tankless Water Heaters

These units are more expensive upfront, costing anywhere from $600 to $2,500 for the unit. However, they offer long-term savings in energy costs.


The size of the water heater significantly impacts the cost. Larger tanks or higher capacity tankless models, which are necessary for larger households, will cost more. For tank models, each additional gallon increases the price.

Energy Efficiency

Models with higher energy efficiency ratings may have a higher initial cost but can provide savings in the long run through lower operating costs. Seek models with Energy Star ratings to gauge efficiency levels and potential utility bill savings.

Installation Costs

These costs can vary significantly based on the installation’s complexity, any required modifications to your home’s plumbing or electrical systems, and regional labor rates. On average, water heater installation costs can range from $300 to $1,500, with more complex installations (like switching from a tank to tankless system) being at the higher end.

Additional Features

Advanced features like Wi-Fi connectivity, digital displays, and improved safety features can add to the cost. While they provide convenience and enhanced performance, they will increase the overall price.

Geographic Location

Labor and installation expenses can fluctuate depending on your location. Urban areas and regions with higher costs of living generally entail higher installation charges.

Removal and Disposal of Old Unit

Don’t forget to factor in the cost of removing and disposing of your old water heater. This can range from $50 to $200, depending on local regulations and the difficulty of removal.

Permits and Inspections

In some regions, replacing a water heater requires a permit and inspection to ensure it meets local building codes. These costs can vary but expect to pay anywhere from $50 to $500.

On average, homeowners typically budget between $800 and $3,000 for a complete water heater replacement, covering both the unit and installation costs. High-end models or complex installations can push this cost higher. 

It’s always wise to get multiple quotes from reputable contractors to find the best balance of cost, efficiency, and reliability for your specific needs. By understanding these cost components, homeowners can better budget for a water heater replacement and make choices that align with their long-term financial and household needs.

Best Time of Year to Replace a Water Heater

Deciding on the best time of year to replace a water heater is a strategic choice that can affect both the convenience of the replacement process and potential cost savings. This decision is often overlooked but can be as crucial as choosing the right model. Let’s explore this aspect from a fresh perspective.

Off-Peak Seasons for Installation

Typically, the demand for water heater replacements and repairs peaks during the colder months when the units are under more stress. Scheduling a replacement during the spring or early fall can be advantageous. During these off-peak times, plumbers and installers may have more flexible schedules and potentially offer quicker service or even discounts.

Consider Seasonal Sales and Promotions

Retailers often have sales and promotions during certain times of the year, such as major holidays or the end of the financial year. Keeping an eye out for these deals can lead to substantial savings on the purchase price of a new water heater.

Pre-Winter Replacement

If you’re planning proactively, consider replacing your water heater before winter sets in. The last thing any homeowner wants is for their water heater to fail in the middle of a cold snap, leading to an urgent and potentially more costly replacement.

Energy Efficiency Rebates

Sometimes, government or utility rebates for energy-efficient appliances have specific time frames. Aligning your purchase and installation with these rebate periods can result in additional savings.

Assessing Your Current Water Heater’s Performance

If your water heater shows signs of wear but isn’t entirely defunct, you might have the luxury of waiting for an optimal time for replacement. Monitor its performance and plan the replacement strategically, keeping in mind the points above.

Installation Considerations

The ease of installation can be influenced by the weather. For instance, in regions with severe winters, external work such as venting might be more challenging. Scheduling a replacement during milder weather conditions can facilitate a smoother installation process.

Budgeting and Financial Planning

If you are budget-conscious, replacing a water heater during a time when your finances are more stable can be a wise decision. Post-tax return periods can be an ideal time for some homeowners.

While there’s no one-size-fits-all answer to the best time for replacing a water heater, these considerations offer a strategic approach. Balancing the practical aspects of installation, potential cost savings, and your personal circumstances will guide you in determining the most opportune time for this essential home upgrade.

Preparing for Water Heater Replacement

Following the strategic decision of the best time of year to replace your water heater, the next step is effective preparation for the replacement process. This preparation is crucial in ensuring a smooth transition to your new unit, minimizing disruptions to your daily routine, and optimizing the installation’s success. Let’s explore the essential steps involved in preparing for a water heater replacement.

Research and Selection of the Right Water Heater

Armed with knowledge from previous sections, choose a water heater that best fits your needs. Consider factors like size, energy efficiency, type (tank or tankless), and budget. Researching and deciding on the right model before contacting a professional can save time and ensure you make an informed decision.

Choosing a Qualified Professional

Look for a reputable and experienced plumber or technician to handle the installation. Ensure they are licensed and insured, and check reviews or ask for recommendations to gauge their reliability and quality of work.

Schedule the Installation

Coordinate with your chosen professional to schedule the installation. Consider doing it during a time when it causes minimal disruption to your household routine, based on the insights from the previous section on the best time for replacement.

Preparing the Area

Clear the area around your current water heater. This step is crucial for easy access and safety. Remove any items that might obstruct the path to the water heater and ensure there’s ample space for the technicians to work efficiently.

Plan for Water and Power Disruption

Be prepared for the temporary loss of hot water. Inform all household members about the replacement schedule to manage expectations. If your new water heater requires different power or water connections, discuss this with the installer in advance to ensure a seamless transition.

Understand the Installation Process

Having a basic understanding of the installation process can help you ask informed questions and set realistic expectations. For instance, tankless water heaters might require additional steps like upgrading gas lines or venting systems.

Disposal Plan for the Old Unit

Discuss with your installer the removal and disposal of your old water heater. Some professionals may include disposal services in their package, while others may require you to arrange disposal separately.

Review Safety and Maintenance Protocols

Post-installation, ask the technician for a brief overview of the new unit’s operation, safety features, and basic maintenance. Understanding these aspects is crucial for ensuring the longevity and efficiency of your new water heater.

Documentation and Warranty Registration

Ensure you receive all necessary documentation, including warranty information. Promptly registering your new water heater with the manufacturer can activate your warranty and provide peace of mind.

Budgeting for Unexpected Costs

While you might have an estimate, it’s wise to budget for unforeseen expenses. Unforeseen complications during installation, such as the requirement for extra parts or adjustments, may result in a slight elevation of the overall cost.

By meticulously preparing for your water heater replacement, you can alleviate much of the stress associated with such a significant home improvement task. This preparation ensures that the process is as efficient and seamless as possible, paving the way for years of reliable hot water supply in your home.

Bassett Services: Your Solution to All Your Water Heater Needs

The right service provider is key to ensuring your home’s comfort and efficiency. Bassett Services emerges as a standout choice for all your water heater requirements. Our combination of extensive expertise, customer-focused service, and dedication to cutting-edge technology positions us as leaders in providing water heater solutions. 

Whether you’re exploring options for a new, energy-efficient model, in need of a professional installation, or seeking dependable maintenance, Bassett Services offers the complete package. We uphold our commitment to delivering expert, dependable, and transparent services, customized to suit your individual requirements. 

At Bassett Services, every customer is a priority, and our team is dedicated to ensuring your water heater is functioning optimally. With our comprehensive services, transparent pricing, and unwavering support, you’re not just investing in a product but in lasting peace of mind. For all your water heater inquiries and needs, make the choice that leads to comfort, efficiency, and reliability. 

Contact Bassett Services today at (317) 360-0054 and take the first step towards a seamless and satisfying water heater experience.

Our Promises